Home foreclosures and market volatility are running high. So any
investment even remotely connected to mortgages is the last place to
look if you're trying to protect your retirement savings, right?
Not necessarily. Many investors seeking safe harbor and modest yield are
finding both in mutual funds that specialize in buying Ginnie Maes,
which are pools of mortgages guaranteed by the Government National
Mortgage Association.
Ginnie Mae, which extracts fees for guaranteeing mortgage investors are
repaid, is a smaller and more conservative player in the mortgage market
than Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Those factors helped the agency avoid
the troubles that ensnared its siblings and led the government to seize
control of Fannie and Freddie in September.
Last year, Ginnie Maes thrived even as Fannie and Freddie suffered.
Nearly
$6 billion flowed into about two-dozen funds that invest mostly in
Ginnie Maes, boosting total assets to nearly $55 billion, according to
fund tracker Lipper Inc.
The niche's newfound popularity lies in its returns. They're modest,
Ginnie Mae funds collectively earned a 2008 return of 5.24 percent,
according to Lipper, with the three-year average annual return at 5.07
percent. So far this year, those returns have fallen closer to 4
percent.
A few considerations for investors thinking of Ginnie Mae funds:
Not all are alike: While it may seem funds investing in the same narrow
category of government-guaranteed mortgages would yield positive returns
year after year, things can go wrong. For example, Putnam U.S.
Government (PGSIX) lost nearly
5 percent last year. Alongside its Ginnie Mae holdings, the fund
invested in collateralized mortgage obligations whose market value sank
because of their high risk compared with other mortgage-related
securities.
Rate volatility: Sudden changes in mortgage rates can make Ginnie Maes
complex investments. Fund managers put cash to work by sifting through
the market for Ginnie Mae-backed mortgages of varying maturities, such
as 30 years and 10 years, and placing bets on the pools of mortgages
offering the best prospects.
Costs count: With Ginnie Maes typically earning only modest returns,
expenses can eat away much of it. Harry Milling, a fund analyst with
Morningstar Inc., said cost should be the top consideration in comparing
Ginnie Mae funds, since they're similar.